TRASH XXII Competition Results – American Amber Ale
Here is how the American Amber Ale I brewed in mid-January 2012 did at last year’s TRASH competition:
Position in flight: 1 of 10
Final score: 30.5
Place awarded: 3rd
Descriptors
Judge 1 (BJCP Recognized): none checked
Judge 2 (BJCP Apprentice): none checked
Aroma
Judge 1: Fresh citrus/pine hop aroma, subtle caramel notes in background. ‘A bit’ vegetal. No off-aromas. Clean 8/12
Judge 2: LIght hop smell, not to malty – clean crisp smells, dry hop smell. 7/12
Appearance
Judge 1: Copper – slight haze – creamy white head – med retention. 2/3
Judge 2: Color is good golden orange, clarity a little hazy, no real head retention, head color white, medium body. 2/3
Flavor
Judge 1: Pine / citrus / grapefruit hop flavor. Very subtle malt background / very slight caramel notes – a little less than expected. Just a bit on the bitter side of balance. 12/20
Judge 2: Malt present little sweet, hops flavor present a little on strong side, pretty citrusy flavor, balance more toward hops and not malt. 12/20
Mouthfeel
Judge 1: Med body, med carbonation, finishes clean & crisp. 4/5
Judge 2: Good mouthfeel, no real warmth little creaminess low carbonation, smooth, some bite. 3/5
Overall Impression
Judge 1: Very nice clean example, need to pump up the malt flavor a bit but very drinkable. 7/10
Judge 2: Pretty smooth, some bite present, overall good presentation, bring down hops, but very drinkable. 6/10
Final Score
Judge 1: 33/50
Judge 2: 28/50
Sylistic Accuracy
Judge 1: Classic Example [] [x] [] [] [] Not to Style
Judge 2: Classic Example [] [] [] [] [] Not to Style
Technical Merit
Judge 1: Flawless [] [x] [] [] [] Significant Flaws
Judge 2: Flawless [] [] [] [] [] Significant Flaws
Intangibles
Judge 1: Wonderful [] [x] [] [] [] Lifeless
Judge 2: Wonderful [] [] [] [] [] Lifeless
Middle of the road results for a middle of the road beer. I’ve brewed this recipe a few times since and keep gettign a similar beer – balanced towards hops and too light on body & maltiness. I think it’s time for me to alter this recipe before I brew another amber ale.



